20 Cute and Memorable Valentine’s Day Gifts That Are Totally Unique (and Not at All Cheesy)

Every couple has “their” special song, and this customizable plaque is the perfect way to commemorate it this Valentine’s Day. Upload a picture of you and your Valentine, include the artist and title of your favorite song, and you’ve got an adorable, shelf-worthy display that your giftee will cherish. You can even opt to add an engraved message to the wooden stand for an extra personal touch.

Out: Boxed chocolates. In? A box of lip balms scented like chocolates… and other scrumptious desserts.

In addition to keeping lips soft, moisturized, and protected from sun damage with SPF 30, these Vacation lip balms come in five kissable flavors inspired by iconic sweets—like After Dinner Mint, Bananas Foster, Strawberry Jello Salad, Bombe Alaska, and Pineapple Upside Down Cake. Split the set with your partner, or show some love to your galentines for a cute and delicious V-day treat.

Available sizes: XXS-XL in standard, petite, or plus fits.

Like we said, we’re a sucker for heart shapes—just as they’re styled thoughtfully. Enter, the Maeve Heart Cardigan from Anthropologie, which is a masterclass in how to wear hearts. For starters, it sports a classic silhouette and shape that can easily be worn on its own or layered over a tank or tee. The pink and red hearts are just the right amount of cutesy, adding a pop of color at the elbows, pockets, and back. Tl;Dr—we love it. And your giftee will too!

For the Valentine that can’t resist a good pun, this personalized spoon makes for an extra cute Valentine’s day gift. Choose between teaspoon, tablespoon, soup, or serving spoon sizes, and add you and your s.o’s initials for a sentimental touch. This is the kind of gift that’s guaranteed to put a smile on your partner’s face every day.

For the Valentine with a sweet tooth, this V-day ready mailer by Wicked Good Cupcakes is a winner. It includes your choice of any two of the brand’s cupcakes-in-a-jar, a card, and a 3D-paper-rose bouquet they’ll want to keep for ages, making it a simple yet effective gift. And with tasty cupcake options like red velvet, cookies and cream, and chocolate raspberry, the hardest part will be choosing your flavors.

Originally $109, now $74

Move over, Snuggies. The Oodie is here, and it’s ready to replace your special someone’s worn-out sweatshirts and baggy tees. The Oodie is practically a hoodie and a blanket mixed together to create the warmest, coziest, most huggable piece of clothing money can buy. Made with a flannel fleece exterior, it’s perfect for chilly mornings or nights on the couch when regular sweats won’t cut it. Get one for your mom, your sister, your significant other, or anyone else on your V-day list who could use some snuggling ASAP.

These quirky heart earrings are a festive addition to your V-day outfit, and let’s face it, the heart motif is always in style, so you’ll get wear out of these year round. The polymer clay earrings are beautifully handmade to order, which means the pair you gift or receive will be totally unique. Take your pick between pink, red, and white color options.

Every faux match in this adorable matchbox has a prompt designed to set sparks flying between couples. In it you’ll find unique date ideas like, “recreate a memorable situation from when you first met,” and “sign up for a class together,” along with quirky conversation starters and small but meaningful ways to show your Valentine that you care, like “do a household task you know your partner hates,” or “find an unexpected moment for a kiss.”

A cute and dainty Valentine’s Day gift for yourself or for someone special, this gold-plated initial necklace has a minimalist, timeless look that’ll make it an everyday accessory. Personalize it with multiple initials of your choice, and add icons for extra flair. Plus, Etsy shoppers love it too—it has over 5,000 reviews and counting!

Available sizes: XS-3XL

For a cute and cuddly Valentine’s Day gift you and your Valentine will want to lounge in every day, the Outdoor Voices MegaFleece Crew Neck is a no-brainer. The relaxed sporty sweatshirt is made of OV’s warmest MegaFleece fabric, which uses 63 percent recycled wool to lock in warmth (without overheating), for a plush (never itchy) feel that’s fit for snuggling.

For a Valentine’s Day gift so cute it’s heartwarming (no pun intended), check out this Heart of Hope Pillow. Handmade using 100 percent cotton, this heart-shaped cushion is stuffed with natural flax seed, buckwheat hulls, and lavender, and can be warmed up in the microwave or cooled down for a soothing, comforting cuddle and to soothe aches and pains.

This perfume-infused bracelet by Diptyque is where jewelry and fragrance gifts converge, making it the best of both worlds. The adjustable, woven bracelet is laced with the brand’s ever-popular Do Son fragrance, which has notes of tuberose, orange blossom, and jasmine, so you can carry its luxe, floral scent wherever you go. Simply cut the bracelet to your desired length, loop it around your wrist and secure it with the included clasp. Each dispenser contains up to 30 scented bracelets!

For the Valentine that prefers tea to coffee, treat them to this tea kit by Sips By. Complete with a heart-shaped mug, heart-shaped tea infuser, your choice of caffeinated or non-caffeinated tea (or both, if you like to mix it up), this cute Valentine’s Day-ready tea set will be the delight of any tea-drinker.

Or, if their coffee cart is already stacked sky-high with caffeinated beverages, give ’em a mug that’ll show their drinks some love. At 14 oz., the stoneware L’Amour mug from Le Creuset is big enough to fill with a morning’s worth of coffee, tea, or cocoa. The heart print is just the cherry on top. Also available in pink or red.

Phlur’s soft and genderless fragrance was designed to mimic the lingering scent of your partner’s skin—and what’s cuter, and more romantic than that? It features notes of white musk, bergamot nectar, and blonde wood, creating a gentle but addictive scent that’s bound to rake in the compliments. And the travel-friendly rollerball in this set means you’ll never have to go without it.

Made in collaboration with psychologists, journalists, and game developers, this fun card game is a great way to laugh and connect with friends and partners over drinks (or mocktails.) The deck is full of unique icebreakers about the things that make us happy—so you can get to know the people you care about on a deeper level and make lasting memories along the way.

To take your Valentine’s Day breakfast in bed to the next level, you’ll want this cute heart-shaped waffle maker in your kitchen. The mini waffle iron is non-stick, and can be used for more than just breakfast—from waffled hash browns and paninis, to cookies and biscuits. And it has over 180,000 5-star reviews, so you know it’s worth the hype.

Fill this linen wrapped photo book with you and your partner’s most cherished memories, and you’ve got a cute Valentine’s Day gift that they’ll continue to look back on for years to come. We love that it can be customized with two lines of gold-foil embossed text (25 characters each), for an extra thoughtful touch.

These hand-poured, 100 percent soy-wax candles can be personalized with a custom message on the box and vessel, for a cute and unique Valentine’s Day gift that’ll have your Valentine thinking of you at every light. And there’s a natural scent for everyone—from spearmint and geranium rose, to lavender eucalyptus and lavender geranium.

This gorgeously illustrated cookbook by Bre Graham is full of easy-to-follow recipes and multi-course menus designed to show love through food. Whether you’re cooking for your partner, friend, or family member this V-day, the recipes in this book are sure to leave your heart and tummy full. Plus, the cover is so cute, you’ll want to keep it permanently displayed on your countertop.